News
Ninth Floor Selborne Chambers is pleased to welcome our new reader, Brodie Millington.
Brodie joins us from Banton Group, where he was a Senior Associate specialising in complex litigation. He has particular experience in class actions, construction and commercial disputes, including the S&P Global, Heavy Plant Leasing, Forge Group and Arrium proceedings. He holds a Bachelor of Laws (Hons) and a Bachelor of Commerce (Accounting) from the University of New South Wales.
Brodie accepts briefs in all areas of law and can be contacted on 02 8915 2158 or millington@selbornechambers.com.au, or through his Clerk, Ella Baxendale, on 02 8915 2101. More information on Brodie, including his CV, can be found here.
We warmly welcome Brodie to Chambers and look forward to his contribution during his reading year and beyond.
The Federal Court of Australia (Downes J) has delivered judgment in EIS GmbH v LELO Oceania Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 1111, in which Katrina Howard SC of Ninth Floor Selborne Chambers appeared, leading James Samargis with assistance from Charlotte Dillon and Melissa McGrath, instructed by the team at Douros Jackson Lawyers, for the successful respondents.
The Court revoked Australian Standard Patent No. 2018200317 relating to a compression wave massage device for sexual stimulation of the clitoris, finding it invalid for lack of clarity, failure to define the invention, lack of support and insufficiency. Her Honour also held that EIS did not establish that the LELO products infringed the Patent.
This judgment is an example of patent claims being found to be unclear and not define the invention. It also provides important guidance on the application of the Raising the Bar amendments to the Patents Act in relation to support and sufficiency. It underscores the need for precision and full disclosure in patent specifications and will serve as a significant precedent in future patent litigation.
See the full judgment here.
Congratulations to Michelle Painter SC for her inclusion in the Doyle's Guide rankings for Leading Wills & Estates Litigation Senior Counsel – New South Wales, 2025.
See the full list here.
Congratulations to Mark Hoffmann KC, Thomas Bagley and Blake O'Connor for their inclusion in the Doyle's Guide rankings for Leading Class Action Barristers, Australia 2025.
See the full list here.











![Andrews & Andrews Construction Pty Ltd v Yao; Yao v Andrews & Andrews Construction Pty Ltd [2025] NSWSC 322](https://9selborne.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/NMM-ARZ-Linkedin.jpg)
![Naaman v Jaken Properties Australia Pty Limited & Ors [2025] HCA 1](https://9selborne.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/High-Court.jpg)














